Vale must come first amid all the bluff and bluster

The statement by Broxap director Robert Lee, in which he attempts to deflect some criticism away from himself for the way in which he undermined the campaign for change at the Port Vale EGM, raises some interesting questions.
Critics have made great play of the fact that the man heading up the consortium to buy the club, Mo Chaudry, only offered to buy the Broxap shareholding for £40,000 – rather than the £50,000 full-price figure.
This enabled the board to do a deal with Broxap the day before the EGM which saved three of the five directors from being ousted when the vast majority of shareholders voted to get rid of them.
On the day of the EGM, Mr Lee told The Sentinel: “We have stated that we have no preferences or issues between the board or Mr Chaudry…”
He went on to say: “We have also stated that whoever owns the club at the start of next season was not our concern…”
However, Mr Lee’s statement yesterday seems to wholly contradict that neutral stance and gives the impression of a man with an agenda.
He has accused Mr Chaudry of: having no interest in the success of Port Vale on the field; plotting to hive-off the property into a separate entity, pension scheme or company which would have long-term negative financial consequences for the independence of the club; and running a campaign which has centred around ‘vexatious propaganda’ instead of engaging in private and confidential discussions with shareholders.
Yet, despite all these misgivings, the fact remains that Mr Lee was quite prepared to sell the Broxap shareholding to Mr Chaudry for £40k.
Furthermore, in an email which I have seen, which Mr Lee sent to Mr Chaudry on May 16, he writes: “We have no reason to doubt your intentions to acquire Port Vale are honourable and if successful I personally think you will become a great charismatic chairman.”
Mr Lee would have to have been on planet Zog not to have known that by agreeing to sell his shares to the board he was, effectively, switching sides and that his shares could prove crucial in such a tightly-contested poll.
Given all this, I personally am taking much of what Mr Lee says with a pinch of salt.
I am not surprised that Mr Chaudry offered £40k because, at the time, it probably seemed like a fair deal.
And anyway, isn’t this the kind of hard-ball business approach that many Vale fans want to see at the club? Because, make no mistake, that’s what they are going to get if Mr Chaudry takes over.
They can’t, on the one hand, demand more professionalism and a cutting edge to the business and then belly-ache about it.
Let’s move forward with our eyes open and accept that anyone wishing to run our club should be open to scrutiny and scepticism until they prove their worth.
I would hope that the current board, Mr Lee and Mr Chaudry would all agree with that sentiment. After all, surely the club must come first.
Frankly, all I care about is that we have a club to support in 12 months, five years and 20 years’ time.
Preferably a successful one where the cancer of nepotism and self-service has been removed.


5 thoughts on “Vale must come first amid all the bluff and bluster

  1. Tony Boulton says:

    This is the same Mr Lee who was unsure about whether he had given Mr Mudie his proxy or not. And by his own admission he is the same man who apparently, unbeknown to us at the time, offered to invest 300k provided the board resigned. Can we really believe anything he says?

  2. Barry says:

    You miss the point that offering only 40k was not, in fact, a demonstration of “professionalism and a cutting edge”. It was, in fact, a demonstration of penny-pinching which ultimately led to Mo failing at the EGM by less than the value of Rob Lee’s shares. It illustrates that Mo is unable to prioritise and I would argue this so called “hard-ball business approach” will not get PVFC anywhere. Barry

  3. Jim Doherty. says:

    Martin, I can see Fleet St beckoning… or is it the Isle of Dogs? Another frank, honest article about the going on at EmmerVALE the soap. Well done. Jim Doherty. Newcastle. Staffs.

  4. Kevin Reynolds says:

    Excellent post Martin,
    Keep it up looks like you can put the major points over what the fans need to know.
    I wish you had got wise to this board earlier.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s